supernatural – Settle For Me: A TV Winner Podcast

111: Hostage Situation

Law & Order: SVU vs. Supernatural

If we’re in a crisis we want Olivia Benson and/or The Winchester Brothers there to help. Good thing these two hostage situations have these characters on hand! It’s Law & Order: SVU vs. Supernatural in Best Hostage Situation Episode: Listen here.

104: Careful What You Wish For…

Dickinson vs. Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Do you wish you could be a famous poet? Do you want to bring your Mom back from the dead? Well, be careful what you wish for… it’s Dickinson vs. Buffy the Vampire Slayer in our latest episode. Listen here.

96: Dream

Twin Peaks vs. Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Today we look at two of the most iconic Dream Episodes with Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Twin Peaks. We also discuss some of our own recurring dreams along with an infamous “dream” movie. Listen here!

77: Alternate Reality

Buffy the Vampire Slayer vs. Supernatural

Right when we all pretty much wish we were in an alternate reality, we look at two shows who wonder what “might have been.” The results…vary. It’s the debut of Supernatural versus Buffy the Vampire Slayer in “Best Alternate Reality Episode.” Listen here!

Episode 45: Backdoor Pilots

Gossip Girl vs. Vampire Diaries

Oh, this is a fun one. We look at two starts of two spinoff TV shows. One went forward, and one did not. But which one do we like more? Listen here.

Episode 42: Crossover

Angel vs. Scandal

Annalise Keating and Olivia Pope on Scandal crossover

Ah, the Crossover Episode: when two shows become one. And, yes, we discuss the Tommy Westphall Theory again. Listen to our thoughts on some very heavy crossover episodes here!

Episode 39: Flashback

BoJack Horseman vs. You’re the Worst

TV Winner beats on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past this week. It’s flashback time! Listen here.

Episode 37: Homage

Dear White People vs. Psych

Yeah, homage is different from parody and we talk about why again here. Or, we try to. Either way, we have a kind of Twin Peaks redemption in this episode and that makes it worth it. Listen here.

Episode 34: Mockumentary

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt vs. Community

Mockumentaries! Mock documentaries. Just like documentaries but funny. Listen here.

Episode 27: Two-hander

Dear White People vs. Parks and Rec

This week we’ve got the sister trope of Bottle Episodes: that episode when two characters go head-to-head. We also achieve a TV WINNER FIRST! Is it the first perfect score? Mmmmmaybe. Listen here.